What We're Praying/Talking About

Our faith in action, or our small contribution in trying to apply what we're taught in Hebrews 5-6 and James 2:17-26 for the benefit of our dear brothers and sisters within the Body of Christ...

February 28, 2012

The Lenten Journey: Repent And...Fast?

I probably should've written and published this piece about a week ago. Better late than never I guess, right?

Come to think of it, the phrase 'Better-Late-Than-Never' is what this entire message today is going to be about! How do you like that? The Lord works in mysterious ways indeed.

I'm ashamed to admit it, but this is the very first year of my young adult life that I've ever really, truly prayerfully considered the meaning of Lent, Ash Wednesday, and my response to such a holy time of the year.

For starters, what is Lent anyway? One Christian gives us a succinct answer...

Lent is as old-school as old-school gets. Doing it justice -- experiencing the real cleansing it implies, and the rejuvenation which is its culmination -- means tapping into some of the more, shall we say, fundamental aspects of Christianity.

If you’re a Christian, Lent is the time for feeling just how real that is, how deeply that goes. It means comprehending that being a Christian goes all the way to literally the very marrow of your bones.

It means getting down on your knees and praying for God to forgive how routinely you squander the gift of Jesus’ terrible and glorious sacrifice for you on the cross.

It means staying rooted in penitential mourning over what happened to Jesus.

It means sacrificing to God and others, and God sacrificed for you and the world.

It means breaking yourself, as Jesus allowed himself to be broken for you.

Old-school, baby!

Feel the hollow, riveting truth of all that God is, and all that you are not.

For forty days, and forty nights, live in the quiet, empty, cold darkness that must come before finally and gloriously the Son arises.

Yes, I know we're supposed to live by faith and not by feelings, but I wanted to share that perspective because I think it gets to the heart of things, and it captures the spirit of it all quite nicely too.

In addition, who can forget the children's nursery rhyme (albeit with dark connotations) that we all learned growing up?

“Ring around the rosy,
pocket full of poesy,
ashes, ashes,
we all fall down!”

Believe it or not, those words are true: "...ashes, ashes, we all fall down!" Hebrews 9:27 guarantees as much.

You will fall down, sooner or later -- if our Lord does not return first -- you will go back to the dust that the Lord used to create us all in the very beginning (Genesis 2:7; Genesis 3:19).

Death is simply the fact of our existence here in this life that we can try to ignore, hide from, and play games with, but, in the end, it’s no game, and there’s no hiding whatsoever. It tracks you down and squeezes the last bit of life from you. And then your breathless clay returns to the dust, the life in it burned to ashes.

It's quite something because while this has been the very first year that I've seriously contemplated all of this as a believer in Christ, such truths were hammered home emphatically for me over this past weekend.

Simply put, isn't it just like God to meet you right where you are? The past few days have proven to me, once again, just how utterly helpless I am, and how fully dependent I am on God for everything. More to the point, it emphasized to me the truth that we can't earn 'brownie points' or 'goodness' with God, but can only rest in the truth that it's what Jesus Christ did, who He really is (imparted to us), and our repentance and faith in Him, that makes us 'righteous' in God's eyes.

In any event, what Satan intended to be an opportunity to whisper his half-truths and lies into my ears, the Lord used to remind me of promises and truths about Him instead. Praise the Lord!

Back to Lent. Did you know that the Lenten season has been known since the Reformation with the word 'Fastenzeit', which means 'Fasting Time'? Ok, but why is fasting associated with Lent? Because this time of year invites us to the discipline of fasting as part of our 'return', or our repentance.

Actually, the word 'return' or 'repent' shows up 1,000+ times in the Old Testament! During this Lenten season, God is calling us to repent, to look at what we have done; to look at what we have done with the gifts that He gave us, to look at what we have done with the resources that He gave us; to look at what we have done with our lives, at what we have done in our relationships. God is calling us today to look at the ways we have despised His Word, and to look at the ways we have offended Him with our sinful thinking and our sinful deeds.

For me, it calls to mind all those 'secret sins' within the 'secret places' of my heart. Remember, He sees in secret, just as Jesus pointed out in the Sermon on the Mount. What will the Heavenly Father see in the secret places of your heart? Something that will make you run away? I know what He sees in mine and I know I need to repent of it immediately.

Joel 2:12-14 is commonly read this time of year. See, you and I are no different than the Israelites to whom the prophet Joel addressed these words. In Joel 1, he tells the people of God that there is an impending judgment that is going to hit the land. Punishment is on its way! Punishment for what they have done! My gosh, that is so relevant to the times we are living in today, isn't it?

It is within this context that the words of Joel are spoken.

Return to me with all your heart, with fasting, with weeping, and with mourning; and rend your hearts and not your garments.

God is calling us to return to Him, not to run away from Him.

It doesn’t matter what we have done. We cannot hide anything from Him because He knows exactly what is in the secret places of our heart. It is for this reason that God expects us to rend our hearts. Yes, that will hurt, but it's worth it.

On the flip side, it doesn’t hurt us when we rend our garments because garments are just stuff. Our hearts, on the other hand, are precious. Our garments cannot hide any of our secrets before God. Besides, Jesus died to mend our hearts, not our garments.

The words from Joel that follow make this call from God look more like an invitation.

Return to the LORD your God, for he is gracious and merciful.

Why run away from a God that is gracious and merciful? Can you see how God, after saying, "Look what you have done!" invites you generously, "Come, because I am 'slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love'"?

When God calls us to look deeply inside us, it is because He wants us to see how much we need Him. He also calls us to look at Him to see how much He cares for us. The season of Lent calls us also to "Look what God has done!" for us. He has done everything for us! He didn’t spare even His only Son in order to bring us back to Him! He is not just a vengeful God, but a merciful God.

There are no better blessings than God’s Son Jesus Christ and His Word. Sometimes we count as blessings the Christian friends that we have close to us, or our families, or the congregations we are part of, or our jobs, or our good health, but when all these are gone, we are still blessed by God because we have the forgiveness of sins and the hope of eternal life.

If I may, I want us to return to Joel 2 for just a moment. "Return to me...with fasting" is what the Scripture says. That was an odd 'discovery' for me because even though I have read this before, even though I have come across the subject of fasting numerous times in other studies, I never actually fasted a single time in my entire life!

Like I said, I'm ashamed to admit that publicly, but that's the truth. Needless to say, I wanted to spend a little time exploring the Biblical description of fasting particularly since it's tied to Joel 2 and Lent.

While 'Giving-Up-Something-For-Lent' has become a popular substitute for fasting, let’s be sure we are clear on what fasting is and what it isn't.

Fasting means not to eat as much. To forego a meal, or a portion of a meal, and to do so with intentionality, and to let that time of hunger pain remind us to watch and pray, to remind us that our hunger should not be for bread alone, but every Word that proceeds from the mouth of God. Fasting is simply to be an aid for our devotional life in the Word and prayer.

But how does one fast? As Christians, we know that there can be no laws about HOW to fast in the Church for the simple reason that neither our Lord nor the Apostles have given us any. There have always been divergent practices on fasting in the Church. Not without reason did St. Irenaeus confess "differences in fasting do not destroy the unity of faith."

One Pastor even put it as follows...

Further, we know that fasting is not pleasing to God when it is offered in any way as a propitiation for sin; then, in fact, it becomes an abomination. There is but one propitiation for the sin of the world and that was offered once and for all by the Lamb of God upon the cross.

So why should we fast? We have to think no further than our Catechism: fasting is "a fine outward training." Now, that was spoken in regard to the Eucharistic fast, but it applies to fasting as a whole. On Septuagesima we heard St. Paul speak of how he disciplined his body, kept it under control, lest he end up being "disqualified" after preaching to others.

Well, if we can admit that fasting is a "fine outward training" the question still arises of what to do?

Many people confuse fasting and abstinence. To fast is to be hungry; to abstain is forego certain kinds of food. The traditional fast of the Western Church was 1/4 meal for breakfast and lunch, with a simple dinner. In other words, for breakfast maybe half a slice of toast, for lunch an orange. Then a regular dinner - but nothing fancy. Something like that was observed throughout the days of Lent. Further, Western Christians have traditionally abstained from meat and wine on the Fridays (and sometimes the Saturdays, and some would say the Wednesdays - all depend on whom you ask) of Lent.

Now, fasting was never meant to live by itself. It is joined to the other two Lenten disciplines: almsgiving and prayer. An increased giving to the poor and an increased time of prayer can go hand in hand with fasting: by not eating so much, you actually have more money to give to others who have less than you, and by not fixing elaborate meals, you also have more time to spend in the Word and prayer. Further, by going hungry each day you experience solidarity with those many members of the human race who also go hungry each day. Above all, we teach ourselves that the hunger behind all hungers is the hunger for God Himself.

In the freedom of the Gospel, we can discipline our wayward flesh by not letting it dictate to us what and when to eat. Give it some thought and prayer and then rejoice in the truth that "man does not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceeds from the mouth of God." Wishing one and all a joyful time of renewal during the upcoming Fastenzeit!

That certainly helps to clarify things I hope.

Here's something else that may shock you because it shocked me and stopped me dead in my tracks: Did you know that our Lord Jesus Christ assumed that His disciples would fast, just as He assumed they would pray?

If you're anything like me, then I bet you suffer from 'Fastphobia' too. Fastphobia is when you constantly downplay the spiritual merits (and Biblical commands) associated with fasting. It's characterized by different phrases about how everyone else is fasting wrong, and especially for the wrong reasons. While that might be true, it doesn't negate the importance of fasting in the Christian life.

This was an excellent commentary from Cyberbrethren that I found on the subject...

Jesus commended fasting as a private act of humility and devotion to God (see Matthew 6:16-18). Note particularly that he says, “When you fast…” not “If you fast…” Take a look at Matthew 9:14-15. The first Christians fasted (Acts 13:2-3; 14:23). Why shouldn’t a 21st Century Christian do likewise? Why?

Because we are, as a culture and society, gluttons. After all, we are a “consumer” society. We consume, consume and consume some more. We eat to the point that our bellies are too large, we weigh too much, and we inflict chronic illness on ourselves brought on by poor diet and exercise habits. I’m as guilty as anyone in this regard. We do not fast to earn brownie points with God, but that fact has become our excuse for not fasting, for not attending to self-disipline and self-mortification. We excuse our laziness and gluttony by appealing to our freedom in Christ as forgiven children. We let ourselves off the hook all the while comforting ourselves that we are free not to get caught up in “legalistic” requirements such as fasting. We look at the required fasts in Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy and rightly criticize the imposition of such rules as contrary to the Gospel freedom we have, but then we again use this an excuse not to fast. We’ll show those legalists, as we continue stuffing our faces and filling our bellies with the food that perishes.

As we now approach the beginning of Lent, it is good to recall that Lent has been, historically, throughout the Church’s history, a time that involves fasting.

If you're inclined to go deeper with this study, then there's The Lutheran Study Bible that has a fantastic article on fasting. You might want to read through it as you prayerfully consider how you will be observing Lent this year.


Afflicting One’s Soul

The modern Jewish calendar has 28 fasting days, but in the Old Testament, God commanded only one annual fast. In Lv 16:29–31, Moses gave God’s dictum to “afflict [deny] yourselves” on the Day of Atonement (Yom Kippur). In response to the atonement for Israel’s corporate sin, devout Israelites would fast from morning until evening on the tenth day of the seventh month. Before the exile to Babylon, Israelites fasted during times of impending danger, mourning, sickness, threat of war, distress, and sorrow. For example, Hannah did not eat because of the great stress brought about by her barrenness (1Sm 1:7), and David fasted after learning of Abner’s death (2Sm 3:35). Religious leaders also mandated periods of fasting at times of great national crisis (cf Jgs 20:26; 2Ch 20:3; Jer 36:9). These examples show that fasting was an expression of sorrow and, most important, an expression of repentance.

Overindulgence

Where faith is strongest, Satan works hardest. While God esteems those who are “humble and contrite in spirit” (Is 66:2), Satan vigorously attacks them with temptations to overindulge. Thankfully, God did not leave His people powerless in their sin. In answer to prayer, God sent Isaiah to call passionately for their repentance and help them understand the true character of fasting as an expression of sorrow over sin and an opportunity to have mercy on the hungry (Is 58:3–8). Unfortunately, instead of heeding God’s call, the people continued in their self-centeredness and thus brought about the Babylonian exile. For God’s people, the Babylonian exile and the destruction of the first temple by Nebuchadnezzar (587 BC) was a turning point in history rivaled only by the Roman destruction of Herod’s temple (AD 70). As a result of the exile, four new fasts were added to the Jewish calendar, each marking key historical dates leading up to and including the exile (Zec 8:18–19). For instance, a fast in the fourth month laments the breach of Jerusalem’s outer wall by Nebuchadnezzar (Jer 52:6–7). A fast in the fifth month commemorates the burning of God’s holy temple and other buildings (2Ki 25:8–9), while a fast in the seventh month marks the assassination of Gedaliah, whom the king of Babylon had placed as governor over Judah (Zec 7:5). Finally, a fast during the tenth month is held in memory of Nebuchadnezzar’s siege of Jerusalem (2Ki 25:1). These fasts served a holy purpose: they reminded the Israelites of the sorrows brought by neglecting God’s Word. However, over time fasting became another way the Israelites abused God’s Word. In the hope of preventing any further captivity, Jewish scholars pored over the writings of Moses, frantically searching for a reason why God exiled them. They determined to apply the Law more vigorously. What followed was a fundamental shift in their belief system. To this day, many Jewish people still believe that if they keep all the laws perfectly, they will gain salvation. Fasting changed from an expression of repentance to compulsory appeasement of a legalistic code. This deception led many astray to spend eternity apart from the Lord, who desires to save all people (1Tm 2:3–4).

The Appearing of Christ

Before the birth of Jesus, the Pharisees mandated twice-weekly fasting (Lk 18:9–12). The Essenes, a splinter group that may have lived at Qumran, centered much of their lives on fasting. For the unfaithful, fasting was something done to curry God’s favor—a duty, a work, a law. But for the faithful, fasting continued as an expression of repentance and reverence for the Lord, who created them and promised to redeem them. After Jesus’ Baptism, He went into the wilderness and fasted for 40 days and 40 nights (Mt 4:2). This recalled the devotion of Moses (Ex 24:18), the great prophet Elijah (1Ki 19:8), and the 40 years of wilderness wandering for Israel. During this fast, Satan repeatedly tempted Jesus, but He used God’s precious Word to defend Himself.

Fasting for You

During the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus spoke against fasting as a means of salvation. Instead, He commended fasting as a private, voluntary act of humility before God (Mt 6:16–18). Take a few moments now to read His words and reflect on your own devotion. If you are like most people, you have thought more about dieting than fasting. It is hard to imagine a daylong fast. No doubt fasting for 40 days like Jesus did after His Baptism is out of the question. Yet our Lord’s words clearly reveal that fasting should be part of a Christian’s life: He said, “When you fast” (Mt 6:16), not “If you fast” (cf Mt 9:14–15). The early Christians fasted (Ac 13:2–3; 14:23). Why shouldn’t a twenty-first-century Christian do likewise? As you fast, let the feelings of hunger you experience remind you to pray. Spend the time you would normally spend eating by reading God’s Word and meditating on the Gospel of Jesus Christ. Through His Word, the Lord will bless and nourish you. “Then shall your light break forth like the dawn, and your healing shall spring up speedily; your righteousness shall go before you; the glory of the LORD shall be your rear guard. Then you shall call, and the LORD will answer; you shall cry, and He will say, ‘Here I am’ ” (Is 58:8–9).

How You Might Fast

Consider fasting for a meal or two before partaking of the Lord’s Supper. Spend your extra time studying God’s Word and singing Communion hymns. Fasting during Lent can be a wonderful way to remember the perfect obedience of Christ and His sacrifice for your salvation. Money not spent on food may be donated for the poor. You might follow this routine for a daylong fast: (1) rise before dawn and eat breakfast; (2) examine yourself as you would prior to partaking of the Lord’s Supper; (3) offer your life to God in penitent prayer; (4) go about your day, breaking your fast at evening. If you are diabetic, fasting could be hazardous. Check with your doctor. Do not consider fasting as a dieting program. If abstaining from food is not possible, consider abstaining from something else. For example, turn off your television and spend time in prayer and study of God’s Word.

Source: The Lutheran Study Bible, page 189.

Ok, so let's quickly recap. Bottom line, fasting is Biblical. For the best directions ever on the kind of fasting that God wants, be sure to read Isaiah 58.

However, fasting should be done as privately as possible and without calling attention to yourself; it has to be with the proper motives. Fast when and how you wish, and no, you never make a 'big deal' of it. Just do it!

Our Lord Christ tells us that when we fast we are to do so without making a show of it, or big deal about it, nor to disfigure our faces, nor to make sure others know we are fasting, but simply just to do it.

Matthew 6 tells us to make sure we don't disfigure our faces to show folks we're fasting, and don’t let our piety be outward stuff. Not showing off in either prayer, or in giving, or in fasting. Let it be secret, hidden, inner and real. It's not supposed to be a performance for others to admire how religious we are. Yet, the irony is that we then dare to go around smearing our foreheads with ashes and wandering out into the public. What gives with that?

The answer, as always, is found in the Word of God. The part of the holy Scriptures that goes with the ashes is the one from Genesis 3. Words from the Creator Himself who shaped us and gave us life. Words from the Lord who had spoken a word of warning about one fruit. Do we remember that?

Genesis 2:17 (ESV) but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall surely die.

Do we also remember the words that God spoke to a frightened Adam and a frightened Eve?

Genesis 3:19 (ESV) By the sweat of your face you shall eat bread, till you return to the ground, for out of it you were taken; for you are dust, and to dust you shall return.

Remember. We need to remember all of these truths during this time of year.

Where's the hope in all that, you ask? The hope is where it's always been -- in the person of Jesus Christ the Lord and Savior!

Think of it! You are forgiven and free because HE owned your idolatry, cursing, disregarding of God’s Word, dishonoring of your parents and other authorities, every hateful word and deed that has left others cut and bleeding, all your sexual sins, your laziness and stealing, your hate-filled and hateful, lying words, your never being content with God’s gifts and always looking for happiness in what He never gave you...

Yes, all that ugliness that the Ten Commandments show as the content of your life and mine. Guess what? HE owned it. To death. It has no hold on you. Not now. Not anymore. You’ve been set free. By His blood. By His death. By His passion. Fear not! Fight fear with faith!

So, Lent starts then as the Lord’s gift of a return. A return to Him, to His embrace and love. You heard it in Joel, "Return to the Lord your God for He is gracious and merciful, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love...the Lord had pity on His people."

Aside from our remembrance so that we can repent, there's also this idea of fasting that goes along with the Lenten journey each year. What do we learn when we examine this aspect of Lent a little more closely?

For starters, the secular world says that fasting can help protect against brain diseases. Funny, because we just examined the Biblical perspective on fasting in relation to a time of the year that encourages us to remember some key truths that are foundational to our faith.

Remember, Christ assumes we do fast -- “when you fast”, he said, not “if you fast”, right? If this is so, then why did fasting fall out of favor? Probably, like most things like this, out of fear of Roman Catholic errors associated with it, and of course there are many such errors lurking and skulking about, but as the old saying goes, “Abuse does not negate use.”

I would like to wrap things up by suggesting you take some time to read Joel 2:12-19, 2 Peter 1:2-11, Matthew 6:1-6, and Matthew 6:16-21. The key point for us? We need to remember some key truths, and return to the Lord our God with all of our heart, mind, and soul.

With Jesus, we set our face toward Jerusalem. We make our pilgrimage with Him by the way of repentance. Each day He summons you and me to return to Him with all of our heart, mind, and soul because He is "gracious and merciful, slow to anger, and abounding in steadfast love" (Joel 2:13).

Let's do so in faith and confidence before Him, supplementing our faith with "virtue, and virtue with knowledge, and knowledge with self-control, and self-control with steadfastness, and steadfastness with godliness, and godliness with brotherly affection, and brotherly affection with love" (2 Peter 1:5–7).

During this Lenten season let's all set aside special times to pray to our Father in Heaven, give to the needy from a heart of love, and fast (in the proper sense, if are able, or at least with the right attitude and motive) for the sake of repentance (Matthew 6:3–4, 6, 17–18).

Almighty and everlasting God, You despise nothing You have made and forgive the sins of all who are penitent. Create in us new and contrite hearts that, lamenting our sins and acknowledging our wretchedness, we may receive from You full pardon and forgiveness; through Jesus Christ, Your Son, our Lord, who lives and reigns with You and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and forever. Amen.

"Better late than never..." Repent now! Death is a certainty and judgment is also coming. It doesn't matter what happened in the past, what situation you find yourself in today, but only that you recognize that you are a sinner, an enemy of God, and that only repenting of those sins and placing your faith in Jesus Christ and what He did on your behalf on the cross, having died and resurrected, is the only thing that will give you forgiveness, mercy, salvation, and eternal life.

Repent, and turn from your sins (John 8:11).

Share|

14 Comments:

holy joe said...

Jred,
'LENT'. Really?!!

What's next ashes on your head on Ash-Wednesday? A Bible believer doesn't need 'seasons' to remind him of what Jesus Christ did for him. We have God's word.

As an ex-Catholic I see the reason for all these 'seasons'. They are designed to ease the conscience - for awhile. Why all the humility only during 'lent'?

I don't need a "LENT" created by the RCC. The Holy Spirit CONVICTS me the moment I sin and I feel terrible about it and repent immediately.
Paul, Peter, John nor anyone else ever taught 'Lent', 'Ash-Wednesday', or any of the other Catholic nonsense. I rejoiced when I was set free from all of Romes chains and here you are dragging them back out as something new.

Brother, I'm really surprised and sorry to read something like this on your site.

holy joe said...

One last thought...
For an historical perspective of 'Lent' and it's true origins please read 'The Two Babylons'(page103) by Alexander Hislop. Written in 1916, Hislop covers how the rituals, practices and observances that the church of Rome adopted into her belief system came directly from Pagan BABYLON. Thus, the Bible correctly identifies her as "Mystery Babylon the Great".
True Born again Christians should have nothing to do with her or her practices.

Anonymous said...

Some good points on fasting and the attitude we should have when doing so. I agree with "holy joe"'s comment that the issue of Lent should have been left out. I am also an ex-RCC member by birth and I fully concur that we don't need the Lent season to walk with Christ.
Cheers,
Martin

Jeffrey K Radt ("JRed") said...

Thank you for commenting.

You know what I'm surprised about? This persistent, self-righteous attitude from my dear fellow brothers and sisters these days (more prevalent from those in online forums like this especially for some reason) that believes that ALL CHURCHES and ALL HOLIDAYS are 'bad' and have no value to 'true' contemporary Christians whatsoever.

I'm sorry, but I don't agree at all. Yes, most churches are apostate, but not all. Yes, most Christians are apostates, but not all. Yes, many celebrate different times of the year for the wrong reasons, but not all. Yes, it will only get worse, but that doesn't mean we completely withdraw and become spiritual islands either, my friend.

With all due respect, holy joe, sometimes I wonder if people even take the time to read a post before commenting, or if they simply see certain words and assume that they know what they're going to read ahead of time.

Case in point, you know perfectly well my position on the Roman Catholic Church and my attempts to speak the truth in love when exposing it for what it truly is so to imply I'm somehow promoting Catholicism is unfair I think. Also, I never once said we NEED to celebrate Lent. I never once said that this is the ONLY time of the year that we should be humble. I merely observed where we are on the calendar and took the opportunity to explore some serious Biblical truths (like repentance and fasting) given where we are on God's prophetic calendar.

So, to act like that's not a noble and worthy endeavour seems ridiculous to me. I wish it weren't so, but if that makes me an 'apostate' myself in your eyes, then I'm sorry because I'm not going to stop taking opportunities like this to study His Word and then write about it here.

In Christ,
Jeff

Jeffrey K Radt ("JRed") said...

Again, I think 5 minutes in the LUF Archive will prove I'm anything but 'pro-Catholic' so I find this early comments in response to this Bible study intriguing.

To reiterate, no one ever said we must celebrate Lent, but that we MUST repent and fast as a normal and regular part of the Christian lifestyle.

It's interesting b/c we actually highlighted that very same work by Hislop in a recent piece published only a few weeks ago back in January (http://www.lookupfellowship.com/2012/01/do-we-already-know-image-of-beast.html) -- in a anti-Catholic commentary/study too, by the way. Here's a brief snippet...

"in the interest of being 'fair and balanced', I should also point out that almost none of Hislop's claims can be substantiated by any reputable source. It's believed that closer scrutiny of Hislop's work will point to the conclusion that outrageous accusation is not the same thing as carefully compiled and decisive evidence.

Furthermore, and this will sort of go hand-in-hand with our recent debate about Christmas, a man by the name of Ralph Woodrow wrote Babylon Mystery Religion. But this honest man has since withdrawn his book (an action which has caused him much financial loss) because of his later honest acceptance of Hislop's flaws. Imagine that.

In fact, you can read Woodrow's frank and honest admission about his Hislop-inspired book and about the errors of Hislop (http://www.ralphwoodrow.org/books/pages/babylon-mystery.html).

Here is just one quote from Woodrow's article to help us to note the flawed reasoning which Hislop so often used and which spread to the cults and sects...

'Some claim that round objects, such as round communion wafers, are symbols of the Sun-god. But they fail to mention that the very manna given by God was round! (Exod. 16:14). Some are ready to condemn all pillars and historical monuments as pagan. But they fail to take into account that the Lord himself appeared as a pillar of fire; and, in front of his temple, there were two large pillars (Exod. 13:21,22; 2 Chron. 3:17).'

If we're all very serious about arriving at the truth of this matter (and I hope we are), about trying to look at both sides as objectively as possible, then I must strongly encourage you to read Woodrow's article in full, plus the book he has now written, The Babylon Connection?, to help put right the freely-admitted errors from his first book on the subject. I've heard it's that good."

I hope that helps clarify my position.

In Christ,
Jeff

Jeffrey K Radt ("JRed") said...

While we're on the subject, Robin A. Brace's comments are appropriate for us at this juncture too.

"Please be aware that in rejecting Hislop's wild claims about Roman Catholicism I am in no way defending error where it is present within Romanist doctrine, indeed, my whole internet ministry is based on exposing theological error (wherever it may be found), but I believe that it is vital for Christian Apologetics and Countercult ministries to ensure that they carefully substantiate all claims."

I wholeheartedly agree. And since Hislop was brought up, bottom line, The Two Babylons is not a book we need to read, and to demonstrate such, that's why I decided to reference a fellow who learned this the hard way (Woodrow), after having written a book which actively promoted Hislop’s misguided view of history.

For the record, I also personally have trouble reconciling Hislop's claim that the coming "image of the beast" will be (or is) an image of a woman because, unless my understanding is flawed, it's supposed to be an image of the Antichrist who we know from the Biblical texts is a man.

Keep Looking Up,
Jeff

Anonymous said...

thank You for the post.

i ve read the link to the man who denounced his book ( and i know hislops work also) , i guess like usually, the Truth is another. Yes its required to be aware of the false (babylonic) symbology - in order to learn discernment, and not let ones energy/belief be stolen (!) by sata*.
But it s helpful to know that sata* , in the first place,stole ALL that same symbology, which was, originally, Hís'.
..and He has worked,througout the whole Bible, (as well as the prophecies pertaining to now), using numerous believers to conquer báck all those symbols/attributes.

Hislop, as pioneer, may ve got carried away a bit; but he was on the right track. Read hów devious Simon Magnus' (satans) mimicking of the Gospel was, and still is,
( link is Scriptural)

http://www.pointsoftruth.com/SimonMagus.html

..and how even the worldstage was prepared for this false gospel

http://www.giveshare.org/babylon/racechange.html

yes ofcourse there are many individuals in a babylonic religion, who are saved. But that isnt the point. The pointis, these structures are satan* powerbase (because of the large number of deceived believers, he imprisons in it!) and these work AGAINST our Lords coming.

bless

Lone

holy joe said...

JRed,

The intention of my comment was not to accuse you of being an apostate. I never did. In fact I never said you were pro-Cathoilc. I know you are not. I believe you are a solid Bible believer. That is why I was surprised in your giving credence to Lent.

Were you raised a Catholic? Taught to "Do your best to please God?",
to perform the sacraments to 'earn God's grace'? I know a side of that religion that you don't. I lived it. It is a trap.
All the trappings are designed to make a person feel self-justified and worthy of heaven.

I 'get' your article.

I have absolutely no problem with fasting and praying. I've done it myself. It is scriptural and I agree that it should be done more often by the individual believer when the Holy Spirit leads. But to pick out a season and say "let's all get humble now" is to miss the true/everyday Christian life.

I bristle at the recognizing of Lent, Ash- Wednesday, Holy Thursday, Good Friday, Advent, Advent wreathes etc. as being Biblical or Christian. They are not taught in the Bible. They are man made. They come from Rome and her false salvation message. Any recognition or observance of them gives credence to that system and THAT is the point of my comment.

Self-righteous, judgmental? If that's what you want to believe about me be my guest. I was trapped in that false system and I'm just testifying to what it is. It gives false hope and all her trappings, as the above, are meant to give a false sense of self-righteousness and to bring together all churches back under her influence and she is succeeding.

It is religion and God hates religion.

Jeffrey K Radt ("JRed") said...

I appreciate the clarification regarding what you are trying to say. Thank you for that.

I know what you mean, and I understand that we don't need to institute holidays to get us to think about what's really important because every day is a holy day if we're truly living it in obedience, service, and submission to Christ.

I guess I'm just wondering if you believe that it is 'wrong' for us to set aside any time of the year to celebrate and worship the Lord, His life, and His Word let alone 'wrong' to go to church of any kind these days because that's the impression I get from your comments here. No, you don't come right out and say it word-for-word, but you don't have to because that sentiment seems implied for sure. If I'm wrong about that, then please, please forgive me, my brother.

Yet, if so, if that's what you believe, and if one's heart attitude/motives don't matter (despite 1 Corinthians 10:31, Colossians 3:17, and Colossians 3:23), and we are to only celebrate what the Bible celebrates in the form of a 'holiday', then I have no choice but to ask if you celebrate the Lord's Feasts? Why or why not?

Furthermore, I know what 'church' is and what it isn't, but should I forsake assembling with fellow believers in a local church building because of the apostastes in the church where I am a member? Or should I stay where the Lord led me, and lovingly (but firmly) do what I can and am supposed to in pointing out the error of their ways in an effort to lead them to admit to their sins? If I am to just cut off all ties at once, then how does that not conflict with Hebrews 10:25?

How far do we want to take this? After all, the Catholic Church is to 'blame' for the current King James Bible, isn't it? Should we stop reading it? Of course, I'm being facetious, and you're already well aware of my views regarding Catholicism (views that you share), but I hope you understand the point I'm trying to make.

Sometimes I just wonder if Satan has done more damage getting us Christians to ignore edifying pursuits under the guise that it is all bad.

YBIC,
Jeff

Michael Angelo said...

JRed, if I could throw my two cents in, I kinda agree with holy joe. I was raised a Catholic too and believe me, a lot of what he says is spot on. Lent, to most catholics I knew, was just another bunch of rules that had to be followed because the church said YOU HAD TO. To NOT do so usually evoked the judgement of being "in danger of committing a mortal sin", in which case, if you died without going through the hocus-pocus of "Confession", then straight to Hell you go my pretty! This was just ONE example of the literal witchcraft hold Catholicism had and still has on people. Unless you were fresh out of "the Box" (any ex-catholic KNOWS what I mean by that), and God forbid, you had just 1 impure thought, it was Purgatory for you. The point was, nothing you could do was ever good enough to give you the peace of mind that, in contrast to accepting the free gift of pardon by our Lord, that you wern't eternally doomed. The WHOLE SYSTEM is works based, being actually very similar to Islam in that aspect. I agree with you that it is Biblical to fast(in the right context and motive) but that just was not the case with claccical, traditional catholics regarding Lent. You gave something up because you had to or were expected to, and then spent the whole montn Plus moaning about it...that is if you made it the whole time of Lent. I know your heart is sincere and fully focused on the Lord, but to compare Catholic Lent with sincere fasting or time spent focusing on the Lord is not compatible. I also realise that with you never having been Catholic, you have absolutely no way of knowing how opressive, frustrating, and frightining it was, especially as a child raised primarily under the old Baltimore Catachism, and then under the mish-mash that evolved from Vaticum2 it was. You never felt forgiven, your salvation was always in question, and, at the very least, Purgatory was in the cards for you. Nevertheless, here by the Grace of the Lord I stand(as do you) washed in the Blood of Jesus, free from past opression of a man-made system. I love this blog and look forward tomeeting you one day either on this planet or at the Wedding Feast(and VERY soon,I hope) Blessings to you and yours.

Jeffrey K Radt ("JRed") said...

First and foremost, I'm sorry you had an experience like that. I really am. Of course, none of that is Biblical. Not the system of 'worship' itself, or the response of many of those 'Christians' in reaction to such 'worship' even.

But that doesn't mean that there isn't a church out there that is doing things Biblically these days, or that there's not genuine Christians out there who are worshipping properly who we should fellowship with on a regular basis. There certainly is! There certainly are!

Plus, I think I understand the confusion here. Who said Catholics have 'ownership' of Lent?

Just as it's flat out wrong for Catholics to react to the season of Lent in all the un-Biblical ways that you laid out for us (an assessment, which, by the way, I completely agree with), I think it's equally wrong for those of us who acknowledge those things to simply ignore a time of year like Lent altogether.

Lutherans celebrate Lent and Ash Wednesday too, believe it or not, but without all the 'trappings' like a twisted works-based theology that you mentioned here. It's simply a time that's used to help Christians focus themselves on the Lord, His Word, and our relationship to Him; to help Christians focus their time and energy spent on prayer and Scripture reading on things like humility, sin, repentance, salvation, fasting, obedience and their relation to the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ that's coming up in a few weeks.

What is wrong with a Christian pursuing any of that? That's my point. It's not about saying, "Hey, there's something about Catholicism I like that we might want to think about this time of year...", but about saying, "Hey, there's something I like about this time of year that all of us as Christians -- not Baptists, Catholics, Lutherans, Methodists, Presbyterians -- might want to think about..." That's a key difference.

In Christ,
Jeff

Jeffrey K Radt ("JRed") said...

I want to clarify a little further.

Unlike the Old Testament, the New Testament does not prescribe a church calendar. Lent became associated in the medieval church with all sorts of rules and superstitions.

For the most part, the Protestant Reformers continued to celebrate Lent, but in a more evangelical way. They cautioned against the connection between fasting and penance "as a work of merit or a form of divine worship," as Calvin put it. But they still celebrated it and used it to evangelize.

Lent is still celebrated today in Lutheran, Anglican, and many Reformed churches. However, many of the English Puritans and Scottish Presbyterians went further, arguing that such observances fostered superstition, constrained the conscience where God had left it free, and undermined the Christian Sabbath as God's appointed holy day. Yet, at the same time, the Puritans did call for special days of thanksgiving and fasting, by order of Parliament!

In my humble view, these special days are valuable chiefly as a teaching opportunity. To be sure, every Lord's Day is a celebration of Christ's saving work.

Paul seems to have allowed freedom to celebrate old covenant feasts, but upbraided those who bound Christian consciences on the matter, especially with fasts and abstinence.

I believe an evangelical celebration of Lent affords us with an opportunity to reinforce rather than undermine the significance of Christ's person and work.

In Christ,
Jeff

holy joe said...

Michael Angelo, myself and other ex-Catholics view 'religious' things differently than other people who come to Christ.

When I trusted the Lord Jesus Christ personally to save my soul I, like the Apostle Paul, counted ALL things, as religion, but dung. Any thing that even resembles religion sets bells off for me. I want no part of it. The Bible warns of false teachers who "Came out from us but are not of us". I don't judge the guy sitting next to me in the pew but I'm sure going to check the guy standing behind the pulpit with my Bible. I'm told to do so in the Bible.

Man has a weakness to want to lord it over people and improve the simplicity of salvation God has won for us.
Religion and tradition is right up Satan's ally. He loves it because he can control man by it. That is why in the new Testament there are no rules governing what day to worship or when to or how often to observe the Lord's supper. We are free in Christ and some leaders just can't stand that vacuum. We step out into dangerous territory when we create things as 'Holydays' Lent, advent etc. because God didn't create them so they are unbiblical. Although well intentioned they are man's attempt to improve the simplicity of God's plan - your complete surrender in love to Him everyday.

You mention Lutherans and other Protestants. When they protested Rome they still carried over baggage from Rome and observe them still today and Rome is using these similarities to pull 'Christians' together. Some Protestant churches are "rediscovering" Mary today. I read in an Episcopal church paper that they were going to host a Gay men's choir. That's where you end up when the Bible is no longer your sole authority.

I'm not saying people are not saved because they observe Lent and other man-made seasons. But I do believe mature believers can see the futility of them and want nothing to do with them. (Please don't read self-righteousness in that comment). I have learned to trust my beloved Bible. If you can't show me a belief is in there then I want no part of it because God didn't think it was needful and didn't put it in His book.

Brother Jeff, I just want to magnify my Savior not traditions. I need no holydays etc. to remind me or help me. We have God's perfectly preserved word and the Holy Spirit. That is all God equipped us with because that's all we need. Our mission is to tell people of God's love for them and that their debt is paid in full. It is up to God to convict them and up to them to believe.

God's method still works and has not changed in 2,000 years. Man has no right to add to it.

God bless.

Anonymous said...

I have to agree with everything "holy joe" said.

We are not saved by works or of man-made doctrines. In fact, when I came to the truth, I made a point to intentionally eat meat on Friday's, just to show my rebellion against it after years of fish.

Also, I too must agree that I'm surprised to read something like this on this site.

An article about repentance or fasting could of been written at any other time, but to connect it the man-made season of lent doesn't sit well with me.

The bottom line for me is, there is no "lent".

Look Up Fellowship Media [LUFM]

Listen to internet radio with Look Up Fellowship Media on Blog Talk Radio

Kingdom Bound Radio Archive

I Want To Believe Radio Archive

Right Now Radio Archive

Fair Use Statement

This is a personal blog, but I've been told that I need to include a formal statement of this nature. So, here goes. This website may contain copyrighted material, the use of which may not have been authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in an effort to advance understanding of cultural, economic, environmental, human rights, political, religious, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a "fair use" of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml&#8221. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond "fair use," then you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.